Wednesday, July 20, 2016

Kids aren't learning in department stores

Read this. It’s remarkable.

“During the last 75 years, engaging low-SES students has been a challenge to public and private school teachers alike. Although most teachers have traditionally succeeded in reaching students who come from middle- and upper-income homes, they struggle to reach economically disadvantaged students.
                This engagement gap is often blamed on ineffective local, state, and federal policies. It is widely acknowledged that poor students are more likely to attend schools that receive inadequate funding (Carey, 2005), pay lower teacher salaries (Karoly, 2001), have larger class sizes, provide a less rigorous curriculum, retain fewer experienced teachers (Barton, 2005), and are less likely to be safe learning environments.
                But if these factors are so compelling, how do we explain the success stories? There is a key bit of evidence missing from this litany of adverse factors: over 50 percent of the academic outcomes of school-age children stem not from public policy but from what the teacher does in the classroom (Hattie, 2008). Teaching matters more than any other factor in a student’s school years. In fact, research (Hanushek, 2005) tells us that quality teaching can completely offset the devastating effects poverty has on students’ academic performance. Here’s how: if any teacher performs at one standard deviation in quality (as measured by student achievement) above the district’s mean adequate yearly progress rate for five years in a row, the resulting improvement in student learning would entirely close the gap between the performance of a typical student from poverty and the performance of a higher-income student. [Bold added.] If you are serious about helping kids succeed, stop wishing for a miracle. Five years of strong teaching is the miracle.
                Although it may be understandable to complain about the “system” or local politics, these complaints do not amount to a valid excuse. With so many Title I schools succeeding, blaming the system is hollow reasoning.” –Eric Jensen, Engaging Students with Poverty in Mind

Now read this. 

“The other party gave us public schools that far too often fail our students. Especially those who have no options. Growing up, my siblings and I, we were truly fortunate to have choices and options that others don’t have. We want all Americans to have those same opportunities. Our schools used to be an elevator to the middle class. Now they’re stalled on the ground floor. They’re like Soviet Era department stores that are run for the benefit of the clerks, not the customers – for the teachers, and the administrators, and not the students. You know why other countries do better in K through 12? They let parents choose where to send their own children to school. That’s called competition! It’s called the free market! And it’s what the other party fears! They fear it because they’re more concerned about protecting the jobs of tenured teachers than serving the students in desperate need of a good education.” –Donald Trump, Jr., America Greater than Ever Before, Republican National Convention

You know, if politicians, spokespersons, powerful businessmen and women, journalists, or even everyday-Joes spoke with one standard deviation greater knowledge of what public schools are actually like (based on observations, opening a book, or even basic parental involvement in their child’s education) America might actually be able to entirely close the gap on small-mindedness and ignorance, producing a nation of human beings that are supportive of each other - growing a body of students that become the bright future that every citizen so desperately desires.

This is not about politics. Donald Trump, Jr. is a human that expressed some opinions about public education. I'd type a response to any sort of public opinion like his, regardless of political affiliation or lean. In fact, I couldn’t care less what stupid animal you, Donald Trump, Jr., the Clintons, or any one else wears on their t-shirts around town. But I do care deeply about kids. I care deeply about kindness. I care deeply about basic education – not just education as in reading/writing/arithmetic, but education of cultures, lifestyles, beliefs, the human race…compassion for God’s sake!

I’m not a parent, but I sure as hell step in for a lot of them when they’re absent. I kiss boo-boos, I give pep talks, I give hugs and wipe away tears of loneliness and rejection. I give students breakfast or a mid-afternoon snack, knowing they might not eat until they see me again the next morning. I encourage students to have a positive self-concept, finding worth in their brains and their hearts beyond an Instagram filter, an allowance, or the social status they hold in their classroom of fellow 8-going-on-18-year-olds. I teach them to love one another and treat others the way they want to be treated. I teach them to use affirmations like, “Yes, ma’am,” not “Yeah,” or “Mmhmm.” I require them to reflect on their actions and set goals for becoming better learners, better friends, better sons and daughters, better workers. I give them opportunities to dream about the future and offer practical ways they can start strengthening their skills – even in third grade – and invite mentors into our school to talk with them to fuel the passionate flames that burn in their hearts for their field. I go home with my little family of students on my mind, brainstorming ways to reach them, engage them, excite them, make them feel safe, build their trust, bridge the gaps in their learning deficits, strengthen their strengths, and teach them ways to cope with stressors and emotions that enter their minds years before those oppressors are welcomed or even expected. I spend my summers preparing a classroom environment that is conducive for the “whole child” and planning lessons and strategies to keep their work time interesting. I take measures to improve myself, so that when in front of 25 little faces, I am modeling healthy, kid-friendly ways to cope with stress, sadness, frustration, or distractions. I lay my personal life aside for theirs every morning when I walk in the door, (with the exception of some funny stores or real-life teachable moments – hey, they need to know I’m human), and “turn on” teacher/mom/nurse/cheerleader/janitor/counselor/coach for the next 8 hours for the benefit of KIDS. Because KIDS are what matters.

I stand among thousands of educators that could read the paragraph above aloud with as much truth and conviction as I wrote it. Thousands. of. us. dedicate our lives to kids – not just August through June, but every. day. No political movement is going to change that, because Dr. Jensen is right, complaining about the system is worthless, and retaining good teachers is the solution. 

So, to Mr. Trump, I say this.


This clerk serves her customers with every ounce of who she is. Perhaps, Mr. Trump, you've been shopping in the wrong department stores.