Thursday, February 18, 2016

The Common Core Conundrum


I’m hoping to ease your fears a little bit with some of the things I’m about to say. Please keep in mind that I’m just a teacher – my job is to love kids with my whole heart and teach them. So that’s what I do. I’m not interested in the politics or the who’s-right-who’s-wrong finger pointing; I’m interested in making the little brains in my classroom a little bit better by the time that they leave me. I’d like to think that because of my central focus, I have a more neutral standpoint than most and can justify it because I’ve taught common core AND non-common core curriculum. These are my observations.

By the end of elementary school, for any child in any system, the primary goal is for students to have number sense. A lack of number sense is the very reason why America has the “he’s 24 and that cashier can’t make change” epidemic. Number sense means that students can not only recite math facts (addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division) but can manipulate numbers and demonstrate mastery of their values. Number sense looks like this for each primary grade, which is really the foundation for all of the others:

K – Make a five. 5+0, 0+5, 1+4, 4+1, 2+3, 3+2, and know the inverse of the fact family: 5-0, 5-3, 5-2, 5-1, 5-4.

1 - Build on mastery of 5s. Make a ten. 0+10, 10+0, 1+9, 9+1, 8+2, 2+8, 3+7, 7+3, 4+6, 6+4, 5+5. Know the inverse subtraction facts.

2 – Build on mastery of 5s and 10s. Make “landmark numbers” (a number that ends with 0). For example, if a student mastered that 3+7=10, they should know that 13+7=20 or that 27+13=40.  Know the inverse subtraction facts. Know doubles. 3+3=6, 4+4=8, 12+12=24, 30+30=60.

3 - Decompose numbers to make friendly pairs. Seeing 42 + 12, I should see 40 + 10 and 2 + 2, exercising my understanding of place value, combining landmark numbers (40 and 10) and adding doubles. Students that have mastered place value and number sense will be able to compute this much faster THIS way than stacking the numbers mentally and adding them the “traditional” way. Try one this way that requires regrouping. Let’s look at 47 + 14. I should see 40 + 10 = 50, (my brain triggers 7+3 when I look at 7+4), 7+3 makes a ten, so that’s sixty, and one more makes 61. (I was AWFUL at math as a kid and a college student because I was too slow and lost track of myself when I was mentally stacking numbers. I started teaching number sense? It’s incredible how much faster I can manipulate numbers and solve problems.) Again. Scary to us “traditional way-ers” but effective for the student who fails to “keep track” as the numbers get bigger.

Since multiplication is introduced in third grade, it also means finding simpler patters to solve more complex problems. Take 7 x 6 for example. Sevens and sixes are hard for kids! If I know my fives, I know that 5x6=30, and that leaves 2x6, which is 12. 12 and 30 make 42! (I, myself, even added those as 10+30=40, plus 2 = 42). The inverse should also be able to be computed with division.


Here's an example of what I'm saying. Example of a Number Talk

While this still sounds a little backwards to those of us who were taught traditionally, there is such a leap in student math fact mastery when they truly understand what those digits mean in their places. (A 4 in the tens place means 4 tens or 40, a 3 in the thousands place means three thousands or 3,000.) When a student can manipulate a problem in numerous ways, it shows they’ve mastered the computation concept, and mastering computation means a higher likelihood of mastering applications (i.e., finding area, algebra, solving word problems, etc.)

The Facebook video shouldn’t have ended where it did. The method that was shown was one way to solve a problem - backwards as it was - not “the common core way” as to which it was referred. Labeling it as such is ignorant. Had she shown 5, 6, or 7 other ways to solve her algorithm, then yes, it could have been called “the common core way.” Common core shows students that, “There’s more than one way to get to my house, so there’s more than one way to do math.” If that round about backwards way is what sticks with even one kid, it’s worth teaching to all of them. How the TEACHER handles assessing the strategy is where an eyebrow should be raised. If a student is being assessed on how to add two digit numbers without regrouping as shown in this video, it shouldn’t matter how the student got to the answer if the process was done correctly. Teachers should assess students on skill/concept mastery, not strategy. State standards and national standards of learning are public knowledge. Unless the standard says, “Students will solve two digit addition problems by counting up to the nearest increment of five, adding tens, finding the remaining difference, then adding the addends to find the difference between original addends,” (which is literally what she did), it shouldn’t be tested that way. The standard likely says, “Students will find the sum of two digit addends from 0 to 99 with/without regrouping.) If a kid brings home an F because they used the wrong strategy, talk to the teacher, and if necessary, seek administrative back up.

Back to the crux of the matter. Common core is often misunderstood by teachers and parents alike and can be misconstrued and mistaught. I have seen it taught HORRIBLY and I have seen it taught successfully. Again, the goal is that all students find a method that works for them to master a learning goal. A master teacher will offer everything she has in terms of skills, strategies, and tools to all students, and will allow the students to choose for themselves the method that has the highest success rate.

As far as reading is concerned, yes, it’s going to be highly differentiated – as it should be. An advanced student deserves content that is going to challenge them and grow them in many ways, just as a lower student deserves the modifications to keep them challenged at the same pace. An “on-level” text simply doesn’t exist anymore. It’s impossible to reach every student that way. (This is across all curriculum – common core and non-common core. A good teacher just does this. Like a plumber fixes a leaky sink, a teacher differentiates. That’s how it’s supposed to work. But like plumbers, occasionally you find a bad one that rips you off. Cold hard truth.)


And to tie a neat bow on it, (and I can only speak from my experience), common core offers the freedom for teachers to develop in-depth units that keep the students engaged in a single topic all day long. Use plants as an example. It was very easy for me to teach a unit on plants that required research, reading, content writing, measurement, local agriculture, art, and testing controls and variables - hitting ALL subject areas ALL day. There was no big transition. It was never, “Okay, kids. Get out your reading books!” Their hands were in it. They were getting messy. They were experiencing the entirety of what there is to learn about plants from every aspect and getting their reading, writing, math, art, science, and social studies without even recognizing it.

Now...today, as a non-common core teacher, I hear myself saying daily, “Well folks, we’re out of time for this. We’ll have to come back to this another time, otherwise we’re not going to cover the *insert subject here* we need to get through.” …because the NON-common core standards have minimal cross-curricular alignment because they’re all pre-paced and mandatory during certain quarters. I DO have to teach compartmentally. We DO have to “clean up” and “move on” after every subject, because not much aligns to make it a seamless learning adventure. It breaks my heart, really. I was a total cross-curricular nerd before I moved. And the students in my new school have such a dim flame for learning compared to where I used to be. Sometimes the hardest work I do all day long is tend to their fire and try to help it grow so they start learning because the WANT to, not because I’m forcing them to.

So while common core may seem scary on the internet, and in some aspects are admittedly a little scary in real life, it’s not the big monster that everyone makes it out to be. Like anything, it has good and bad characteristics, but the MOST IMPORTANT factor in any of it is a teacher that loves kids and TEACHES. More often than not, you’ll find those, because Lord knows we don’t do this for the paycheck.